It’s human nature to compare. Whether it’s people, situations, or in this case, hockey players, we instinctively relate what we see to what we know. It helps us make sense of the present by connecting it to the past, and in hockey, it’s why young prospects are so often likened to established stars.
Of course, no two players are exactly alike. A comparison doesn’t mean a prospect will follow the same career trajectory as his counterpart, but similarities in style, role, or demeanor can remind us of those who came before. With that in mind, here are a few comparisons between today’s Canadiens and some notable names from the past.
Juraj Slafkovsky
There have been plenty of attempts to find the right comparison for Slafkovsky. Initially, I saw shades of Robert Lang—a big forward, not overly physical, but one who uses his body effectively. Then, as Slafkovsky started embracing the physical side of his game, my perspective shifted. Now, I see more of a young John LeClair, particularly before his trade to Philadelphia, when he was just beginning to showcase his potential. A strong skater with a big frame, some offensive flair, and a willingness to play the body—though not necessarily in bone-crushing fashion. Although he’s been more physical since the 4-Nations break… If Slafkovsky consistently keeps up the physicality, I can see a parallel with a former Bruins: Cam Neely.
Kaiden Guhle
If you’ve followed my work, you won’t be surprised by this one. I’ve made this comparison before, and I stand by it—Guhle reminds me of a young Shea Weber. Having watched both play junior, I see similarities in their calm demeanor, professionalism, and low-key personalities. Weber had a heavier shot and was more physically imposing, but Guhle is a better skater. Aside from that, the parallels in their playing style, leadership qualities, and approach to the game are striking.
Arber Xhekaj
WiFi has drawn comparisons to Sheldon Souray, but I don’t quite see it—Souray was far more offensive-minded. Some have likened him to Lyle Odelein, which I think is closer, though I believe Xhekaj has more offensive upside. A decent match within the Canadiens’ organization would be Ben Chiarot, but even that isn’t perfect. Instead, I look outside Montreal and see shades of Marty McSorley. Tough as nails, a better skater than people give him credit for, capable of putting up points, and responsible enough defensively—Xhekaj embodies much of what made McSorley an effective player.
Cole Caufield
Many want to compare Caufield to Martin St-Louis, but I don’t see that. Instead, I see a smaller winger who carved out an impressive career in the Western Conference—Paul Kariya. Like Kariya, Caufield isn’t known for his physicality, but he’s a better skater than he gets credit for, shiftier than many realize, and a more skilled passer than most acknowledge. This season, he’s also shown significant growth in his defensive play, making the comparison even more fitting.
Nick Suzuki
Finding a true comparable for Suzuki has been challenging. Some, including Jonathan Drouin, have pointed to Patrice Bergeron, and when you break down the numbers, it’s not a bad match. After 400+ NHL games, Suzuki and Bergeron are nearly identical in many aspects of their game. If there were ever doubts about Suzuki’s ability to be a true number-one center, they should be put to rest by now.
Lane Hutson
As with Guhle, I have to go back to a player I watched closely in his rookie season to find the best comparison. Whether it’s his skating, elusiveness, offensive instincts, or underrated defensive improvements, Hutson is a near carbon copy of Quinn Hughes in his early days. If his development continues on the same trajectory, Canadiens fans will have plenty to be excited about.
What Do You Think?
Do these comparisons resonate with you? Are there other players—past or present—who come to mind when you watch today’s Habs? Part of the fun of being a hockey fan is seeing history repeat itself in new ways, as young stars carve out their own legacies while reminding us of those who came before. Share your thoughts in the comments—who do you see echoes of in today’s Canadiens?
